Music Blogs

Could Beyonce Have Stopped Kanye From Ruining Taylor's Moment?

Posted Wed 7 Oct 2009 2:13PM NZDT by Billy Johnson, Jr. in Hip-Hop Media Training

Can Beyonce share some of the blame for Kanye West's MTV Video Music Award meltdown that resulted in him ruining Taylor Swift's first Best Female Video win moment?

The "Halo" singer recently told O Magazine editor-at-large Gayle King that Kanye talked to her before he rushed to the stage.

http://a323.yahoofs.com/ymg/hiphopmediatraining__4/hiphopmediatraining-690313370-1253303071.jpg?ymgcX6BDWZabLRKpAccording to MTV, Beyonce addressed the incident Friday after accepting the Woman of the Year honor at the Billboard Awards.

"Well, I knew his intentions, and I knew he was standing up for art. And he told me before, when they said the nominees, he's like, ‘You have this award,'" Beyonce explained. "And when they didn't call my name he was, like, completely shocked. And when he walked on the stage, I was like, ‘No, no, no!' And then he spoke, and I was like, ‘Oh, no, no, no!'"

Beyonce felt some relief because the spotlight ultimately returned to Taylor. "It ended up being a great night, and Taylor Swift did get her moment, and I didn't have to make an acceptance speech," Beyonce added.

I am surprised to hear Beyonce's side of the story. When I wrote my initial blog immediately after watching Kanye's tirade, I made the point that he clearly did not have any friends who were able to be honest with him.

http://a323.yahoofs.com/ymg/hiphopmediatraining__4/hiphopmediatraining-9867510-1253569725.jpg?ym9iY7BDx_TEObUoThe fact that he told Beyonce that he was upset makes me consider how Beyonce could have handled the situation.

While we all need friends who will tell us when we are out of line, at the end of the day, we are responsible for our actions. So I don't consider Beyonce an accomplice in this case.

However, I think that Beyonce could have made more of an effort to deter Kanye from humiliating Taylor.

Let's try some role playing based on Beyonce's account of what happened.

VMA Announcer: The nominees for Best Female Video are...

Kanye: Oh, Beyonce, you have this award.

Beyonce: *smile*

VMA Announcer: And the winner is...

Kanye: *fidgeting, sitting on the edge of his seat*

Beyonce: *giving Kanye, the evil eye a mother gives her child who is throwing a tantrum in the grocery store*

VMA Announcer: TAYLOR SWIFT

Kanye: *eyes roll back* Oh, h*** no! H***-to-tha-naw!

Beyonce: KANYE! *grabs his arm to stop him from moving* You better not embarrass me. It's okay. SIT DOWN. I am NOT playing with you! *gives him the evil eye again* Amber Rose, you better grab your man!

--The End--

Unfortunately, waiting until Kanye got on stage to start saying "No, no, no" was waaaaaay too late. (Wait a minute. Wasn't "No, No, No" Beyonce's first hit with Destiny's Child, when she was 17?)

Kanye has a history of getting out of line at award shows. So once he started getting agitated it should have been clear that his next move would be rushing the stage.

Consider this. We all have at least one friend who is rude, and will embarrass the entire group when out in public. We already know what sets them off, and can tell before it happens. And sometimes we don't invite them places. Kanye is that person.

We need to create a buddy system program for rude people. It can be modeled after the Friends Don't Let Friends Drive Drunk campaign. I'll let you know when I come up with the slogan.

Follow Me On Twitter.

Follow Yahoo! Music On Twitter.

 

532 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
Well u cant predict what people will do when they have a low tolerence for rules and u should not even some blame on Beyonce, she was just as suprised as the rest of us.

2. Yahoo! Music User -
"I knew his intentions", that should say it all. Now you and Swift have been humiliated, but wait you can still save the day. Ah oh, it's a songbird, no it's a yoddler, no it's it's Super Sasha.

3. Yahoo! Music User -
As a friend and as a nominee, Beyonce should have defused Kanye. Beyonce giving Taylor her acceptance speech time was the only option left really, since Kanye's little rant was all about Beyonce. Beyonce had to save-face or have the audience turn against her as well. Beyonce and Jay-Z both excused Kanye's actions... in the name of "Art".

Perhaps this was a boost for Beyonce's ego.

4. Yahoo! Music User -
Can't blame Beyonce for not holding back Kanye. What was she supposed to do? Physically restrain him? Once a jacka$$, always a jacka$$. The "standing up for art" comment is ridiculous. Art is is the eye of the beholder. What about Taylor Swift's art? How about one of those country boys rush the stage when she's accepting an award? Would she excuse that as standing up for art? I guess Beyonce and Kanye were both cut from the same block.

5. Yahoo! Music User -
Beyonce is not Kanye West keeper or mother for that matter. If his mom didn't teach him manners an how to handle his self in public then why should Beyonce try to raise him all over again.At the end of the day she did the right thing by letting Taylor Swift shine at the end with her. Showing class and decorum and if that didn't teach Kanye something then treat him like a child and give him a time out like they do children.

6. Yahoo! Music User -
Shoulda', coulda', woulda'.......

7. Yahoo! Music User -
we all know that kanye's got a reputation for making a fool of himself but this time he had to drag the poor beyonce with him.

8. Yahoo! Music User -
mr billy you are a journalist, i can understand that. so u dig for dirt where there shouldn't be any. but don't make B Look bad. kanye is an adult and B is a married woman.you can't treat kanye like a three year old, and you can't expect B to make a scene trying to hold kanye back from doing something she couldn't have imagined. who in the history of these awards does that? kanye did it on impulse and stunned everyone...even B.

9. Danielle -
Beyonce don't make excuses for the jack ass.

10. Yahoo! Music User -
Well well well- I am an avid Beyonce fan and am appauled at the thought of her being held responsible for someone else's actions. What if she had not been there then no one would have even considered her. Yes she may have been aware of his intentions but she is not responsible for him and his actions. Only responsible for hers and as you all can see her true actions showed when Taylor Swift was given her moment. Truly an act of class and decorum and what type of person she really is.

11. Yahoo! Music User -
When it all comes down to it the question is: "Am I my brother's keeper?" In this case, no. Kanye West is a grown man, and though he may have issues, ultimately at the end of the day, adults have to be held accountable for their actions (unlesss he is found to be mentally defective, which may be the case and he's undiagnosed). When in the public eye, he can act as bipolar as can be with his unpredictable behavior; the only thing that is for certain is his unpredicatability.

12. Yahoo! Music User -
no way Bey should not be blamed for what Kanye did he is still a child and children do what children do they strive for attention. even though i am only 18 i would still know how to act in front of people. he needs to be spanked!!!!

13. Yahoo! Music User -
My opinion is that every adult should be held responsible for his or her own actions. Kanye's rants and tirades of many previous awards shows is a reflection of his character, childish and ignorant in the least. I mean, how mature was that? Pure unadulterated IGNORANCE... Beyonce gave no indication that she KNEW he was going to rush the stage and make an A$$ out of himself, she knew he felt that she had that in the bag so to speak. So, everyone including B was taken off guard and he should carry that cross by himself.

14. Teamone S -
To say that Beyonce could have stopped Kanye's rant is like saying that anyone can stop a moving car from hitting one of their loved ones if the car is coming right at them. I feel that the incident could not have been stopped no matter who would have tried to prevent it. Its unfortunate that Kanye did what he did, but I find it worst that your still blogging about this and not moving on to bigger and better things.

15. jeannie -
i feel that beyonce is just as much to blame.i feel that her reaction during his rant showed that she felt the same way and if she could,she would have went up to protest it.i dont believe that she is as innocent as she pretends;she only let taylor have her moment when she saw that the crowd was not amused by his actions like she was amused by it.i truly feel that she knew he was going to do that and had to cover up her involvement in it.i thought she might have a little class,but that is not the case.while i dont listen to ms.swift's music,i do believe in having some kind of respect for other artist.btw,the excuse was standing up for art-if you consider being sexual and dancing nasty is art,then we have a long way to go.and no,her video is not the best of all time,it looks and sounds like all of her other songs.i think i speak for many when i say kayne is NOT the voice of black people so please do not think that we all agree with his comments,outbursts and behavior.

16. Yahoo! Music User -
Either way, I dont think there's any way to stop Kanye. Hahaha

17. Meridius D -
does anyone actually care about this? I mean c'mon.

18. chriskegbarry -
Why are we still talking about this when Mitchell Henderson's ipod is still missing?

19. Yahoo! Music User -
Perhaps it was just his racist tendencies seeping through...

20. cHeMiCaLxRoMaNcE -
Friends don't let Friends be Kanye West...
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
Attention, Attention
by Shahlin Graves
32
Chartalec
by Andrew Miller
21
Framed
by John Kordosh
119
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
219
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
332
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
123
Rap It Up
by James Castady
28
Sub Pop Rock City
by Luke Oram
29
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
124
The Eclectic
by The Eclectic
37
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
88
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
513
More News Stories